Comment It still works like shit. (Score -1) 11
I've used these "vibe coding" tools. Cursor, Claude Code, VS Studio Copilot, ChatGPT API in NeoVIM, etc... They absolutely suck. They waste more time than they usually save except for very specific tasks. They can occasionally create working code for smaller problems, but it's not code you want to check in. It's full of other bugs. They are usually logic bugs or oversights due to the context tokens being exhausted and the bots "forget" about various parts of the project that's already done or rules/decisions you already made. The threshold right now is about 300 lines of code. Get past that, shit falls apart rapidly.
Don't get me wrong, bots can occasionally code. However, unlike for writing copy, creating images, or making music, the code isn't "good enough" to use or continue building with. If you do, you will regret it. Sure, have it write docs, review code, etc.. but as for writing the solution itself: it's garbage. People just lap these stupid journo stories up but they rarely talk to skeptical real coders with AI experience.
When will the world learn that nothing is going to effectively shortcut having to code in large projects. The bots simply fail in real-world projects. They make the code substantively worse and more confusing. There is no silver bullet. There never was. CASE method was bullshit. Visual coding didn't make managers into coders. New methodologies like Agile or XP only made working life more miserable and add admin slots for non-coders. There is no shortcut to writing code that really works long term for big projects. PERIOD.
Don't get me wrong, bots can occasionally code. However, unlike for writing copy, creating images, or making music, the code isn't "good enough" to use or continue building with. If you do, you will regret it. Sure, have it write docs, review code, etc.. but as for writing the solution itself: it's garbage. People just lap these stupid journo stories up but they rarely talk to skeptical real coders with AI experience.
When will the world learn that nothing is going to effectively shortcut having to code in large projects. The bots simply fail in real-world projects. They make the code substantively worse and more confusing. There is no silver bullet. There never was. CASE method was bullshit. Visual coding didn't make managers into coders. New methodologies like Agile or XP only made working life more miserable and add admin slots for non-coders. There is no shortcut to writing code that really works long term for big projects. PERIOD.